I loved my F650 - it was my first motorcycle. This bike taught me how to ride; it was a forgiving and loving creature that put up with all of my inexperience and mistakes. It took me to places flung far from home, showed me freedom, adventure, and brought calmness to my heart, my head and my soul. This mechanical companion was my guardian as I traveled on adventures that would roll over 3,000 miles under her single cylinder Rotax engine. With that being said, it would be very hard to not have a jaded opinion towards this bike. However, the days of my 650 were numbered, and like a true guarding, she sacrificed herself as a Chevy Silverado pulled out in front of me as we were traveling 60 miles per hour. I survived; the bike did not.
I then had a decision to make. Buy a used F650, a new F800GS, or take advantage of a very sweet deal I could get on a brand new 2008 R1200GS. I went the route of the R12. It was not the same as my 650, but I was very excited to have a new bike, and to be riding again. The bikes are different; the R1200 is WAY faster, almost scary fast. It seems like this bike can pretty much keep up with or out perform a lot of the sport bikes out there. It won’t touch a liter bike or a supersport, but I don’t think there is any other bike on the planet that can do what this bike does on the road, and then get down and dirty off-road as well. While truthfully my F650 had plenty of power, enough for me - the difference between the 650 and the 1200 is something beyond night and day. To counter that advantage, I would say that in my opinion, the F650 had a wider power band than the R12. It seems like I could be in just about any gear on the 650 and not have to downshift. Sure I did not have peak performance if I was in 5th gear and slowed down to 40 or 30 without downshifting, but the bike would roll back up to speed without ever complaining. If I were to try that on the 1200, it would bitch fiercely and shutter as the engine lugged back into its peak operating range.
As to off road handling, as weird as it may sound, it seems that the 1200 actually performs better off-road than the 650. There is a huge difference in suspension. If I were riding my 1200 with a skilled or even moderately skilled rider on a 650, I am sure that the 650 would leave the 1200 in the dust. But this is a comparison of my opinion of both bikes and so far, the 1200 seems to handle the dirt better. It may just be that I myself am better at riding off-road, and it is not the bike at all – but when I compare the two, I feel the 1200 handles it better, despite being around 60 lbs heavier. I have ridden over obstacles on the 1200 that would have put me on my ass on the 650.
Aesthetically I think the 1200 looks better than the 650. A lot of people do not agree with me on this point, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder and I have always admired the look of the big GS’s and wished my 650 looked a little more like it’s big brother. I think the biggest thing for me was the beak and headlight. I always thought these two items had more appeal on the bigger bike. Any time I rode it, I would always get people admiring and looking at my F650, mostly when it was parked somewhere. It was a great looking bike and I was complemented on it often. However in the short time I have had the 1200, I have probably already had more people comment on it than 2-1/2 years of ownership of the 650. People routinely stop beside me in traffic and shout out “nice bike” from their car windows. Beauty may be held in the eyes of those casting the gaze, but it seems a larger sect of the population agrees with my eyes.
There is absolutely no contest when looking at mileage and range. The 650 is a very dominantly clear winner in this field. The dual spark single of the F650 would generate 70 MPG on a consistent, day-in day-out basis. There were times when riding the mountain roads in Colorado that I would get up to 96 MPG out of this efficient machine. The lowest gas mileage I ever had to put up with was 56 MPG from a tank when coming home at 85 – 90 miles per hour on a fully bagged out and loaded bike. To date, the best I have been able to squeeze out of the R1200 is about 45 MPG. Of course almost every tank run through the R1200 has included some city traffic, but at almost 3,000 miles on the OD, I am guessing it is probably not going to get much better. Although the tank held about a gallon less fuel, I could easily get 200+ miles out of a tank before the fuel light would come on, and then I knew I had around 70 miles left in the tank. The low fuel light on the R12 comes on around 170 and I probably have right at around 40 miles in the tank. I don’t know that this is going to be a big problem when traveling, I usually tend to stop every 2 – 3 hours anyway when riding, but the comfort zone of knowing I could still go another 70+ miles when the fuel light came on is going to be gone.
There is very little doubt that the 1200 handles better than the 650 – at least once you get used to riding it. I feel much more comfortable leaning into turns on the 1200 than I ever did on the 650. I’m not sure why that is, perhaps the suspension. The 1200 is a bigger bike though and while it handles better when riding at speed, you have to learn how to handle it at low speeds; it turns wider and feels a bit more top heavy than the smaller counterpart. The 650 seemed to be more agile as well. While I am getting used to, and learning how to flick the 1200 around, it was effortless on the 650, and although the additional power certainly helps you get around other vehicles, I felt that the 650 was a better bike in heavy traffic. Of course that may be 26,000 miles of handling one bike vs. only 3,000 miles on the new bike. The only real handling complaint I would have about the 1200 is that it seems to be a little less sure footed when riding over city titties in a turn. It feels more like I would loose traction than it did on the 650.
One thing I am still having a hard time believing is that the air/oil cooled 1200 runs at a lower temperature than the liquid cooled 650. I know the opposing cylinders of the 1200 is a huge advantage in keeping the bike running cool, but even when stopped in 100 degree Texas heat, I really don’t feel the engine heat. I used to feel the heat from by 650 while I was moving, even in cooler weather (which was not always a bad thing by the way…).
As to working on the bike, I was used to and comfortable with doing just about everything on my F650. One of the reasons I choose the R1200GS over the F800GS is that it seemed that everything on the 1200 would be easier to get to and to work on. Of course you have the final drive, but I have some experience with drivelines from working on the machines at my job. The shaft drive is much cleaner; I don’t have to put ATF on the chain after every tank. While talking about final drives, one of the things I liked about the 1200 was that it seemed like it was geared pretty low, as low as my 650 with a 49-tooth rear sprocket and stock 16-tooth front. Of course the issue is that I cannot change the gearing on the 1200 unless I really got into the bike. The 650 was just a change of a sprocket and chain.
Riding at highway speeds truthfully does not feel that much better than it did on the 650. This is the thing everyone always told and/or tells me. That I am going to like the 1200 much more on the highway. In some respect that is a true statement, especially when riding over 70-80 MPH. However, I really do not feel that much of a difference at a steady 70MPH between the two bikes. Sure there is a difference, and of course the 1200 has abundant additional power waiting in the wings at that speed that was not present on the 650. However my month old memory between crashing the old bike to purchasing the new one, did not find a significant difference.
Well, that is my evaluation of the two bikes. Right now, I have to say that I prefer the 1200, but of course I would – that is what I am riding. However if someone were to ask me which to buy, outside of taking the Chinese built engine of the G650GS into consideration. I would steer most first time dual sport riders to the F650. If they were coming off of something with a lot of power then I would recommend the 1200. Hopefully after 23,000 more miles on the new bike, I will find it treated me just as well as the old bike (rest it’s soul).

